If you have the physical journal, you can look for the following characteristics to determine if it is peer-reviewed. Masthead The first few pages: Include information about the submission process, the editorial board, and perhaps even a sentence indicating that the journal is peer-reviewed. Publisher: Peer-reviewed journals are usually published by: 1. Peer review issues. Peer review is the formal quality assurance mechanism by which scientific manuscripts, e.g. journal articles, books, grant applications, and conference papers, are subject to the scrutiny of others people, whose comments and judgments are then used to improve the works and make final decisions regarding the Heart Campus, Southfield Road, Middlesbrough. BX, Tees Valley. m.chen tees.ac.uk. Dr Mark Chen is a Senior Lecturer in Sport and Exercise Science at Teesside University and a Chartered Psychologist with the British Psychological Society BPS. Dr. Chen's research interests include psychological consequences of sports injuries, scholarly journals, including peer-reviewed journals. Check this box to search only scholarly journals, including peer-reviewed journals. Leave the box blank to include other sources in your search. A publication is considered scientific if it is written by academics and intended for a primarily academic target audience. The printed format is generally not.